I’ve been wanting to write about my MIL for some time now, but since we haven’t seen her in a while, I can’t seem to generate the required anger and frustration to churn out a really good post about her. I also had to get permission from AJ to write about her on a public blog.
We only see MIL once every 2 years (she lives in Colombia), mainly because AJ can’t stand her. That works for me, because I can’t either. But then around the 2 year time frame, he starts to feel guilty for being a bad son, and buys her a ticket to come visit us. He buys the return ticket for 5 days later, because that’s the longest he can stand to be around her. So any post I write would have to encompass the whole 5 days and there’s a lot of shit that happens in 5 days with this lady. I just went back and reread the venting email I wrote to my friends after she left the last time, and there’s some good stuff in there, but it’s freaking LONG.
In general, though, every single one of her trips has followed this timeline:
Days 1 and 2: Everything is great. She’s in a great mood, happy to be with her son, happy to see me, happy to not be in Colombia. Her biggest desire is to move to the US so she spends the first 2 days on her best behavior: cooking, cleaning, organizing… as if to say, “Look how wonderful your life would be if I came to live with you.” On day 2, though, the subtle guilt trips start to come out: how poor she is, how she can’t afford simple things because we don’t give her enough money (AJ and his sister pay her a monthly allowance which covers all her bills. She can’t hold a job and has always relied on handouts from friends and family. This is why we can’t afford to bring her to the US because it would take a lot more money to maintain her – at least, that’s what we tell her. If she were normal we’d totally bring her here. Well if she were normal, she’d have a job and be able to come here on her own).
Day 3: Due to the increasingly aggressive guilt-trip comments, AJ starts to get snappish with her. Then, when we’re in a public place (usually in a restaurant), something he says will set her over the edge and she’ll exclaim, “How you can say something like that to me!” Then she’ll start bawling (very loudly) and pawing exaggeratedly through her purse yelling, “I need a tissue! I need a tissue!” and asking waiters and strangers if they have a tissue. It is too bad I am not telling this to you in person, because I do a great impression of her. It’s all very dramatic.
Day 4: AJ and MIL stop speaking to each other. I have to listen to how that son-of-a-bitch (AJ’s father) cheated on her (not true) and left her struggling to raise two children by herself with no money from him (also not true – he supported them during all the years that AJ and his sister lived with her, but she never told AJ and he didn’t know that his dad supported them until much later). And how she worked so hard (according to AJ, she did nothing but watch TV all day) and she made him who he is today (she physically and emotionally abused him, and it left deep scars). She’ll also throw in that AJ’s sister sucks as well and they’re both ungrateful and make her live in poverty and she always has to beg to be able to come see them. She’ll say all righteously that she can’t blame her kids for preferring their father, after all he is rich, not like her (he’s also NORMAL, not like her), but she wishes they would feel just a tiny bit of appreciation for everything she sacrificed for them (AJ left her at age 14 because he couldn’t take it anymore and went to live with the man his mother always referred to as “the asshole” – that’s how bad it was, he would rather live with an asshole than with his mother). And so on and so forth. I usually just nod a lot on day 4 and try not to slash my wrists.
Day 5: AJ starts to feel guilty for having made her cry – despite all her histrionics, she’s really good at what she does (manipulation and getting things out of people). He usually spends day 5 taking her shopping and buying everything she wants. Day 5 is not good for our bank account. Then after we drop her off at the airport, AJ will say to me, “I am NEVER inviting her to stay with us again.”
I once stumbled upon an article about narcissistic personality disorder, and it described AJ’s mother to a tee. She really does not seem to have the capacity to love, and uses her children for personal gain. The article said that those with narcissistic personality disorder use love as way to manipulate others, and when the other person is no longer willing or no longer able to give them what they want, they accuse the other person of not loving them anymore. AJ’s mother totally does this to him, to his sister, to other family members, to friends. To her, “showing love” is “buying whatever the fuck she wants” but it’s never enough. She seems unable to comprehend “but I can’t afford it.” I strongly suspect this is why AJ’s father divorced her. She is never be happy, never satisfied.
She often tries to cause friction between AJ and his sister, bad mouthing one of them to the other. Once she got AJ’s sister so upset at AJ that they didn’t talk for 6 months. All based on lies. She is unable to hold onto friends as well. Because she is so charming and so personable, she makes friends very easily (AJ got that from her)… but then loses them just as quickly once they realize how manipulative and grasping she is. She is unable to hold onto a job because everywhere she works, “for some reason” her coworkers always end up “turning” on her, they all hate her and they’re all out to get her. She has some serious issues and sadly, she is too old to get help for it – and anyways, she doesn’t recognize that she has issues. Everyone else has issues, not her.
Luckily for me, AJ is always on my side. He does not allow her to be anything but nice to me, and he has indicated to her that in any choice between her or me, he would choose me every time. This makes her visits a bit more bearable for me, because he is pretty good about shielding her from me. AJ’s BIL is not so lucky. AJ’s sister is not as strong and she cannot defend herself as well. So her husband defends her, and then he and MIL go at it. Then AJ’s sister and her husband fight because she stands up for her mother. Once, MIL went to visit them – it was supposed to be only for 2 weeks but she ended up staying for 2 months because AJ’s sister did not have the nerve to make her leave. She later told me that they almost got a divorce that time. I can’t say I blame BIL. I can’t imagine not having AJ on my side when MIL visits.
When I first became a mother, many wonderful childhood memories came flooding back to me. People with kids know what I mean. I had a great childhood, and I had fun remembering all the good times my brothers and I had as kids. Everything I did for my kids would remind me of how my mother or father used to do it for me and my brothers. I remembered things I hadn’t thought of in years, and it would make me smile and feel loved. It made me really appreciate my parents so much more.
It was different for AJ. Yes, many childhood memories came back to him, but they were bad memories, things he had suppressed for a long time. He had shared with me a lot of awful things MIL did, but after having kids, he remembered even more. Since becoming a father, and knowing he would give his life for our children, it is unfathomable to AJ how a parent could treat her children the way that MIL did/does. He went through a phase of extreme anger at his mother for the things she did to them.
The last time MIL came to visit was the first time AJ had seen her since we had children. Because of all the anger he’d been feeling towards her, the day 5 shopping spree did not happen. In fact, he was so disgusted with her that after she left, he told me he really was done with her. She probably realized something changed, because after she went back to Colombia, she wrote him a long letter about forgiveness and how it can take the weight off your heart if you just forgive the past. Something like that. He forwarded it to me with no comment and I had to plug it into the Spanish-English translator (which is really inaccurate). But I got the gist. He never replied to that email, or any of the subsequent emails she sent.
So that was about a year ago. Usually AJ starts to feel the guilt of “not being a good son” around 2 years after a visit, so we have another year to go. It was really different last time, though, so I don’t know what will happen next year. He’s changed his attitude toward his mother a lot since becoming a dad (way more negative and not as susceptible to guilt trips).
It’s sad because his mother really is a very charming, very intelligent woman, but she uses it to manipulate people. When you meet her for the first time, you’re just so entranced by her. She is attractive, friendly, funny, worldly, and interesting. Sometimes we wonder what she could have made of herself if only she’d been normal. What a waste of a life! Well, not a complete waste, since AJ would not exist without her.
The biggest annoyance is that no one gets how awful she is, because people only meet her once or twice when she is at her most charming. AJ’s stepmother is always talking about how being a single mom is really hard and that he should “just let it go”. But I don’t think AJ’s dad and stepmom know about the abuse and it’s not my place to tell them (I once asked AJ how could his dad leave his kids with their mother if he knew what she was like, and AJ said that his dad probably did not think she could hurt her own children). AJ hears it from his friends as well. People who just don’t get what it is like to have an abusive parent. He used to hear it from me in the early days of our relationship, but then I talked to a friend who had an abusive childhood and she told me it is very, very difficult to forgive and move past it, so I am a lot more understanding now. Even my dad finds the idea of an abusive mother so impossible that he DOES NOT BELIEVE that it actually happened, that maybe AJ “misunderstood” things she said or is exaggerating about the beatings or something. These days the abuse is only verbal and comes in the form of guilt trips, manipulation, putting him down, etc. Some of the things she has said to him in front of me are so awful I can’t believe a mother would say them to her child. So yeah, I fully support him if he decides to remove her from his life.
Anyways, with that intro, I’ll probably post more little tidbits about her later on as I remember them.